• Twitter
  • Facebook
News-Sentinel.com Your Town. Your Voice.
Opening Arguments

Another Indiana first

In a culture where sound bites define presidential campaigns, what's more natural than debate by billboard?

Indianapolis, Indiana) "Would Jesus discriminate?''

The question has been popping up on billboards, yard signs and in newspaper ads around conservative central Indiana lately in a new, Bible-based appeal for acceptance of gays and lesbians. It's a campaign organized by a predominantly gay and lesbian denomination - Metropolitan Community Churches - and a Jewish gay activist.

Organizers say the effort is the first in a planned series of campaigns across the United States aimed at getting people to take a fresh look at the social justice passages in the Bible.

``Jesus taught us to love everyone, even our enemies and those who are different from us, not destroy and mistreat them,'' said one ad published in the Indianapolis Star.

Not sure how far this campaign to push Christians' discrimination-guilt buttons will get. Aren't Christians supposed to live by a certain set of principles, risking eternal damnation if they get it wrong? That's not only discriminating, it's downright judgmental. And they need to be careful with the "love our enemies" metaphor -- following that path does not require us to passively let them do whatever they will with us.

Stick with the civil-rights arguments and trying to influence legislation. That might be a more complicated and time-consuming approach, but it's the best way to win converts in our freewheeling republic.

Posted in: Hoosier lore

Comments

Doug
Thu, 07/13/2006 - 6:01am

"And they need to be careful with the "love our enemies" metaphor -- following that path does not require us to passively let them do whatever they will with us."

John
Fri, 07/14/2006 - 11:09am

Oh, I'm sure Jesus wasn't serious when he said that. It's not difficult to figure out when he was joking. If what he said sounds too difficult for you to follow -- he was joking.

Turn the other cheek - a joke.
Give aid to the lepers of society - a joke.

Petersen
Sat, 07/15/2006 - 6:17am

Morris writes: "Aren't Christians supposed to live by a certain set of principles, risking eternal damnation if they get it wrong?"

No. That is not a Christian teaching. It is, however, a common stereotype, and quite convenenient when one wants to dismiss the morals espoused by Christianity. The logical fallacy here is "the straw man," though "tu quoque" is certainly implied, making it also a kind of ad hominem attack. But such logical fallacies are somewhat necessary when logic fails, and are the stuff of political campaigns. It is too bad that in this post they are also the stuff of Opening Arguments.

David Petersen

Steve Towsley
Sat, 07/15/2006 - 10:54am

Hey, I think we need more guilt billboards. Road signs: "Would Jesus block the passing lane?" Business offices: "Would Jesus take 'whatever the market will bear?'" The hood: "Would Jesus gang bang?" Everywhere: "Would Jesus sell drugs?" "Would Jesus use drugs?"

Eventually we'll have individual signs for sale at Home Depot: "Would Jesus leave HIS dog waste on MY lawn?" or "Would Jesus park in my space?"

Would Jesus make light of a Jesus sign fad? Probably.

Quantcast