• Twitter
  • Facebook
News-Sentinel.com Your Town. Your Voice.
Opening Arguments

15-13 and a pair of scissors

Let the revolution begin!

City-County Councilman Ed Coleman is leaving the Republican Party to become a Libertarian.

"I have found that the direction of the Republican Party has changed, and it is not the same party I joined many years ago," he said. "Nor do I believe its current leaders truly represent the ideals that the party markets and advertises to voters."

Council President Bob Cockrum said he was surprised by Coleman's defection but noted the balance of power on the council will not change. The new makeup of the council is 15 Republicans, 13 Democrats and 1 Libertarian.

I guess it really isn't much of a revolution when somebody is elected as one thing then comes out of the closet as something else. But it's probably the only way to get a Libertarian on most elected bodies. It would have been a lot more interesting, though, if the makeup were 14, 14 and 1, wouldn't it?

As someone who has always had at least libertarian leanings, I've noticed that allies come and go. Back in the days of my yout, the libertarians and liberals seemed like allies in disdaining government authority, with the Vietnam War the biggest thing on most people's minds. In recent years, libertarians and conservatives have been together on fiscal restraint.

There is a movement afoot these days to create something called "liberaltarianism," which I don't think will get any more traction than libertarian paternalism did a couple of years ago. Libertarians (especially the big-L variety) are the original purists, much more interested in advancing their philosophy than actually winning elections and participating in government. They run with scissors much better than they play with others.

Coleman said he jumped ship when he became disillusioned with GOP abuse of power: "During the council's previous period of Democrat control, the majority's powers were used to silence Republicans," Coleman said. "Now, under Republican control, the council majority abuses their power to weaken Democrat influence." Well, that's politics for you, messy as it is. I suspect poor Mr. Coleman, now a minority of one, isn't going to become any less disillusioned with the real world.

Do you suppose there are any closet Libertarians (or even libertarians) on City Council? Mitch? Tom? Liz? Sometimes I even have suspicions about Karen.

Comments

Doug
Wed, 02/18/2009 - 10:23am

Not sure how together libertarians and conservatives are in fiscal restraint. Conservatives in elected office haven't actually demonstrated much in the way of fiscal restraint despite the rhetoric. Of course, I guess you could say that they're "together" with libertarians in the sense that libertarian fiscal restraint never gets much beyond rhetoric because they don't win elections. Which, perhaps, raises the question - can you actually practice fiscal restraint and win elections?

Leo Morris
Wed, 02/18/2009 - 11:12am

I've come to think "fiscally conservative Republican" might be an oxymoron.

tim zank
Wed, 02/18/2009 - 11:48am

Republicans have proven to be fiscally irresponsible, cavalier, money spending morons engrained in the political cesspool that is the beltway. We (us Republicans) have been handed one more chance to pull our collective heads out of our arses
and return to conservative principles, and while I'm hopeful, I'm not yet convinced we can pull it off without shedding the RINO hierarchy we are saddled with.

Term limits!!

eric schansberg
Wed, 02/18/2009 - 1:23pm

Doug is conflating/confusing GOP with FC. To his point, few FC's get elected either.

Michael B-P
Wed, 02/18/2009 - 2:37pm

From the musty archives of a liberal arts education:

Orthrus was Geryon's two-headed dog and Geryon, a three-headed three-torsoed six-armed Titan cowherd bully
assassinated by Hercules.

When thinking 'Democrat vs Republican,' think Orthrus.

Quantcast