• Twitter
  • Facebook
News-Sentinel.com Your Town. Your Voice.
Opening Arguments

The moderate flogger

Careful what you put in writing -- it will come back to haunt you. Greg Walker, mainly an anti-abortion candidate, didn't really make public flogging part of his successful campaign to unseat longtime Indiana Senate President Pro Tem Robert Garton. But he did, once upon a time, speak favorably of it in a letter to the editor in the Columbus Republic. Now, it's all anybody wants to talk about:

Still, Walker wouldn't back down from his stance. While saying anti-abortion legislation would be his top concern as a senator, he defended flogging as a biblically based punishment.
"It's not a core value for me, but it's part of the inspired word of God, so I know it works," he said. "If that makes me a radical, then so be it. I'll accept the label. But I don't think it's a radical position."
Actually, it's the definition of a radical position. Walker, however, defines flogging as a "compassionate" alternative to jail for some people convicted of crimes such as drug abuse or being drunk in public.
Ahh, yes, compassionate whipping? I can't imagine why Walker didn't make that his campaign slogan.
That brings up an interesting idea. Would you accept public flogging as an alternative to a week in jail? How about instead of a year in prison? Think about it. Sure, there would be some humiliation involved, but you'd get a certain amount of sympathy, too. The pain would be over relatively quickly, and you'd still have the next year free. Hmmm. Maybe the deterrent value isn't quite as strong as Walker supposes.

Comments

ROACH
Thu, 06/01/2006 - 12:49pm

So lets return to the days of the old west; and Allen county, for that matter.
Whats wrong with "hanging by the neck until dead"(as compared to only halfway dead- time off for good behavior?)

Hemp rope is pure from nature, not a product from a pharmaceutical company, or chemical company.
Hemp Rope is cheaper than lethal injection, and you dont need to find a suitable vein.
Hemp rope is relatively painless, compared to other methods of capital punishment.
Hemp Rope is reusable, recyclable.
Hemp rope doesnt pollute the atmosphere, like a gas chamber.
Hemp Rope uses no energy, like the electric chair
Hemp rope relys on gravity to work, something we will always have.
Hemp rope doesnt cause Lead poisoning, like firearms, (asif)
Hemp Rope hanging from a gallows standing in "Jailhouse flats" serves as a constant reminder and deterrent to would-be criminals.
And when you're done with hemp rope, you can always smoke it...

Why mess with a proven technology, used for centuries for just the types who really deserve it. its better than "hanging around" a prison for life, costing the taxpayers money.
And hanging is fine for inmates , like simon rios, and ronrico hatch, who both should do the right thing, and hang themselves
a well hung suggestion....not to be confused with "rope-a-dope"(hemp is a dope-rope)
hope you got a laugh, with my "gallows humor"....

Quantcast