• Twitter
  • Facebook
News-Sentinel.com Your Town. Your Voice.
Opening Arguments

The unkindest cut

Here's your word for the day: innumeracy. It's the mathematical equivalent of illiteracy, and it helps explain how the federal budget has grown to such monstrous proportions. An agency's funding is proposed to be increased by, say, $100 million, but then the increase is reduced to $50 million. Opponents decry a "50 percent cut in funding," and the press uncritically echoes it, never mind that what we really have is a $50 million increase in funding.

Case in point: Tracy Warner chides Indiana U.S. Rep. Mike Pence because he "supported a bill to take a step in the right direction by cutting $50 billion -- from social service programs like Medicaid." In point of fact, that "cut" was to reduce the growth from 7.3 percent to 7 percent. Try to find that in a news story -- I dare you.

As Pence asks: "Where else but in Washington, DC could a Deficit Reduction Act that actually increases entitlements by 6.3 percent instead of the planned 6.4 percent be called a cut?" Where else? In Fort Wayne, that's where.

Even if that were a real "cut" in social-services spending, it seems picky to jump on it, considering that we've just seen the start of a Medicare prescription drug plan estimated to cost more than $700 billion in the first 10 years. If you want to know how much $1 billion is, learn a little from a college student.

We are in the path of a fiscal hurricane, and when liberal editorial writers and "conservative" presidents seem equally oblivious, it's hard to see how we can get out of its path.

Comments

LP Mike Sylvester
Tue, 11/22/2005 - 7:22pm

Barry Goldwater would be a Libertarian today, that is how far the Republcians have shifted on fiscal matters.

I too am tired of people WRONGLY labelling the 50 billion dollar deficit reduction as a cut. They have not cut anything, the programs are still going to grow at between 6.3% and 7% a year.

I always thought that a cut meant that the funding next year was LESS then the funding this year...

Quantcast