• Twitter
  • Facebook
News-Sentinel.com Your Town. Your Voice.
Opening Arguments

History isn't real to them

Peggy Noonan on the "low information leadership" of the Obama team:

From what I have seen the administration is full of young people who’ve seen the movie but not read the book. They act bright, they know the reference, they’re credentialed. But they’ve only seen the movie about, say, the Cuban missile crisis, and then they get into a foreign-policy question and they’re seeing movies in their heads. They haven’t read the histories, the texts, which carry more information, more texture, data and subtlety, and different points of view. They’ve only seen the movie—the Cubans had the missiles and Jack said “Not another war” and Bobby said “Pearl Harbor in reverse” and dreadful old Curtis LeMay chomped his cigar and said “We can fry a million of ‘em by this afternoon, Mr. President.” Grrr, grrr, good guys beat bad guys.

It’s as if history isn’t real to them. They run around tweeting, all of them, even those in substantial positions. “Darfur government inadequate. Genocide unacceptable.” They share their feelings – that happens to be one of the things they seem to think is real, what they feel. “Unjust treatment of women—scourge that hurts my heart.” This is the dialogue to the movies in their heads.

There’s a sense that they’re all freelancing, not really part of anything coherent.

Pretty perceptive, I think, especially from someone who had praise for the president early on. Maybe she's more devious than I give her credit for and she was just heaping false praise on him because Hillary Clinton terrified her. But she's one of the conservatives -- George Will and David Brooks included -- who gave Obama early credibility. Welcome to reality, folks; better late than never, I suppose.