There have been two categories of anti-smoking zealotry I think went too far:
1. Jails: Put a bunch of antisocial, mostly violent people together in close confinement, then tell them they can't smoke.
2. Mental institutions: Try to help people hanging onto reality by their fingernails by taking away their cigarettes.
I might now add this third category:
The state's tough new anti-smoking law has an unlikely opponent: a retired doctor who argues the ban is forcing elderly smokers in nursing homes to take unnecessary risks.
Dr. Robert Guild, 71, says the law is forcing him and other smokers at the Maplewood Gardens Retirement Apartments — some in wheelchairs and walkers — to brave an ice- and snow-covered lawn to get to a structure that is far enough away from the retirement facility to meet the ban's requirements.
