• Twitter
  • Facebook
News-Sentinel.com Your Town. Your Voice.
Opening Arguments

Who's in charge?

Hey, my alma mater is famous again. No, not for the Letterman-Oprah gabfest. It's a court case to answer the burning question, "Who's the boss around here anyway?"

Fourteen years after deciding that employers can be liable for workplace harassment by supervisors they employ, the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday appeared to struggle with an issue left unanswered: who qualifies as a supervisor.

A decision in the case against Ball State University, brought by a black catering assistant named Maetta Vance, could clarify how readily harassment victims may hold deeper-pocketed employers accountable under federal law.

Several justices questioned where best to draw the line, a task made harder by the agreement of the parties arguing in court that the standard set by the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago in dismissing Vance's case was too strict.

In that June 2011 ruling written by Judge Diane Wood, considered one of its more liberal members, the 7th Circuit said that to be a supervisor, an employee must have the power to hire, fire, demote, promote, transfer or discipline the victim.

Three federal appeals courts have adopted this standard, while three others have said day-to-day oversight is enough to result in liability. A definition proposed by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission resembles the latter standard.

Seems like splitting hairs to me. Even if those providing "day-to-day oversight" don't havethe direct ability to fire, demote, etc. us, they have the ability through their reports and reviews to influence those who do. And short of that, as justices from across the political spectrum noted, they have the power to make our work lives so miserable we have no choice but to quit, which could be considered the equivalent of firing.

Of course, this whole workplace-harassment issue is so full of vague generalities and subjective perspectives that it remains highly problematic as a matter of law and justice, but that's a whole other issue.

 

Quantcast